Albert Fentress The Murderous Cannibal Teacher From Poughkeepsie, New York

Knoji reviews products and up-and-coming brands we think you'll love. In certain cases, we may receive a commission from brands mentioned in our guides. Learn more.
The heinous and murderous cannibal teacher from Poughkeepsie New York, Albert Fentress, fights for his release from the many Psychiatric Centers located in New York after murdering and mutilating an eighteen year old young man back in 1979.

In the dark and humid evening on August 20th of 1979, 18 year old student, Paul Masters was roaming the backyard of then Poughkeepsie middle-school teacher, Albert Fentress. Local teenagers were known to pester or mildly harass Albert Fentress.  Fentress possessed rather odd behaviors and a strict disposition while teaching in his history class. Surprisingly, administrators at the Poughkeepsie middle-school permitted Fentress to fashion himself with Nazi military uniforms and wield a leather riding crop while teaching students WW II history in class. He also was permitted to dress in fashions of other time periods in his teaching lessons and act in character, role playing within those time periods he dressed and reflected upon. Some parents and students perceived this to be a unique teaching approach, as others thought it to be bizarre and quite peculiar. Apparently, he was very well versed in the subjects he lectured and taught about.

Fentress was an avid stamp collector and treasured the finer luxeries of life. Driving a Cadillac and always finely dressed, he was described as a lonely but meticulous man living in his very well kept and tidy home. In the summer months of 1979, his house was burglarized and his fine stamp collection was stolen. He was then compelled to apply for a gun permit which was granted by New York state. This burglary may have also contributed to Paul Masters and other teenagers in the neighborhood vandalizing and lurking about the property of Fentress, as gossip spread among their peers of the community and throughout the school regarding the stolen stamp collection. Fentress kept watch, secretly peering out of his home for anymore would-be burglars and harassing vandals. To the deadly misfortune of teenager Paul Masters, he roamed into the backyard of Fentress. Fentress was able to lure Paul Masters into his home by offering him a beer over friendly conversation. Suddenly, the conversation  turned into a desperate attempt for Paul Masters to save his own life.

Albert Fentress attacked the young man eventually subduing him after a brief struggle. He then bound him tightly with ropes to a pole within his cellar. Fentress then proceeded to sexually assault the young man and out of frustration in his psychotic state of mind, Fentress then shot him twice in the head, then mutilating him by castration and decided to cook and eat the young man's genitals. After releasing the now dead Robert Masters from the bound ropes, Fentress dragged him upstairs into his bedroom and fell off to sleep. After awakening the following morning, he called a friend describing what he had done and was arrested that day, making a confession of his macabre cannibalizing murder of Robert Masters. Apparently two days before the murder, Fentress wrote what could only be described as a screenplay or short story detailing the torture and murder of a teenager, essentially in the same way that he acted out in real life just days later. From all accounts, he says he was so abashed at what he wrote, he then burned the manuscript. This chronicle of true crime gets even worse.

After a year of legal wrangling with psychiatrists and lawyers defending this murderous madman, he was found not guilty by reason of insanity. Even more shocking and disturbing is the fact that Albert Fentress may possibly be released back into society because of many attempts by psychiatrists and lawyers to declare he is now a sane man. In 1997, a psychiatrist and professor of behavioral sciences, John Oldham, was commissioned to assess the Albert Fentress case and he determined that Fentress was not mentally fit to be released back into society contradicting other professional psychiatric determinations. Quoting the psychiatrist - “If he couldn’t handle kids slashing his screens and burning his lawn, then how could he possibly handle the likely public reaction to his release, after he'd been demonized in the media as 'New York's own Hannibal Lector?'” Fentress then filed for a jury trial for his release, as it is his right under a rare implementation of New York state law considering his plea of insanity and found to be not guilty in a court of law. In the court of public opinion though, he is a ghastly murderer and should be behind bars or receive the death penalty for his crimes. Psychiatrists have diagnosed Fentress as suffering from dissociative fugues, obsessive personality disorder and narcissistic personality disorder.

In 1999, based upon psychiatric documents, a Suffolk County jury determined that Albert Fentress was no longer a threat to society and recommended his release and freedom from the Pilgrim Psychiatric Center. After the court proceeding, Fentress was returned to the Pigrim facility while Judge Harry Seidel of the State Supreme Court considered a motion by prosecutors to overturn the jury's decision to release Fentress back into society. As Judge Seidel deliberated over the motion for a jury trial, citizens, prosecutors, lawyers and other psychiatrists were outraged and confounded at the jury's decision to release Fentress and continued diligently to keep Fentress from release of the Pilgrim Psychiatric Center. This reaction and travesty of justice sparked, then Governor George Pataki, to comment - ''Justice can never be achieved as long as individuals like Albert Fentress can commit vicious crimes and hide behind an insanity plea to avoid the prison time they deserve. ''The Fentress case illustrates the glaring need to reform our state's laws that allow criminals not only to escape conviction and punishment but to avoid confinement in secure facilities.''

To avoid any long and drawn out appeals process, Judge Seidel ordered a jury trial to proceed for Fentress's release. When his prosecution and eventual not guilty plea by reason of insanity withstood at that time, Fentress's lawyer, Kim Darrow didn't ask Fentress on the stand about the heinous murder of Paul Masters. So prosecutors were unable to, by law, question Fentress on the events of that fateful August evening. Therefore, jurors were unaware of his original charges and crimes. The jury trial was based upon the release of Fentress according to psychiatric reports that stated Fentress was a sane man, when in fact, he is not. Unfortunately, the jurors decision in this case was a victory for Fentress. As they deemed him still mentally ill, but not ill enough to have to remain incarcerated at the Pilgrim Psychiatric Center.

In a statement to Dutchess County's District Attorney's Office, father Burt Masters had this to say - ''I'm angry with Mr. Fentress. He always seemed he was more interested in himself. I never heard him say he was sorry for what he did to my son. I think he's always just been sorry for himself." But the case of Albert Fentress did not end here for the torture and murder of Paul Masters. Not long after the outcome of this jury's decision, the New York state appellate court upheld the presiding judge's determination to overrule the jury's verdict, which meant keeping Fentress institutionalized. In another twist of fate for the victims and murderous Albert Fentress, two other victims came forward in 2002 and testified in great detail how they were too, sexually molested by Fentress while attending the same Poughkeepsie middle-school in 1979, several months before the heinous murder of Paul Masters. In light of this new testimony by these two other victims, Supreme Court Judge James Catterson ruled Albert Fentress to still be very dangerous to society and ordered Fentress to a more secure facilty at the Mid-Hudson Psychiatric Center in Goshen, New York. In accordance to New York state law, if Supreme Court Judge James Catterson rules against Fentress in his upcoming appeal, this murderer will be granted another trial.

Image credit - aftermathnews.files.wordpress.com/2006/

18 comments

Add a comment

0 answers +0 votes
Post comment Cancel
Tom Wolfe
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Aug 6, 2012
Jeremy Maier
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Jul 18, 2012
Pat Bartels
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Mar 28, 2012
Guest
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Feb 15, 2011
michael helweg
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Feb 5, 2011
DeeBee
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Aug 2, 2010
swati
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Jul 29, 2010
M 5446
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Jul 6, 2010
Elle
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Jul 5, 2010
lisa leverton
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Jul 5, 2010
Phoenix Montoya
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Jul 3, 2010
Rachel Ellis
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Jun 28, 2010
Ron Siojo
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Jun 27, 2010
Lauren Axelrod
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Jun 26, 2010
Tanya Wallace
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Jun 26, 2010
Richard Wing
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Jun 25, 2010
deepblue
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Jun 25, 2010
Joe Dorish
0
This comment has 0 votes  by
Posted on Jun 25, 2010

About This Article

Richard Wing

Explore Top Health & Medical Advice Stores

Psychology Today Review Compare Psychology Today vs. top competitors See Psychology Today Coupon Codes 1mg.com Review Compare 1mg.com vs. top competitors See 1mg.com Coupons Marie Claire Review Compare Marie Claire vs. top competitors See Marie Claire Promo Codes Philips Lifeline Review Compare Philips Lifeline vs. top competitors See 4 Philips Lifeline Promo Codes ADT Health Review Compare ADT Health vs. top competitors See ADT Health Discount Codes Wellness Mama Review Compare Wellness Mama vs. top competitors See Wellness Mama Coupons MedBroadcast Review Compare MedBroadcast vs. top competitors See MedBroadcast Discount Codes Bel Marra Nutritionals Review Compare Bel Marra Nutritionals vs. top competitors See 3 Bel Marra Nutritionals Promo Codes Dr. Sinatra Review Compare Dr. Sinatra vs. top competitors See 74 Dr. Sinatra Discount Codes PatientsLikeMe Review Compare PatientsLikeMe vs. top competitors See PatientsLikeMe Promo Codes Dr. Whitaker Review Compare Dr. Whitaker vs. top competitors See 77 Dr. Whitaker Coupons Teladoc Review Compare Teladoc vs. top competitors See Teladoc Discount Codes Cardinal Health Review Compare Cardinal Health vs. top competitors See Cardinal Health Promo Codes Dr. Hyman Healthy Living Store Review Compare Dr. Hyman Healthy Living Store vs. top competitors See 2 Dr. Hyman Healthy Living Store Coupon Codes Request A Test Review Compare Request A Test vs. top competitors See 7 Request A Test Promo Codes Invite Health Review Compare Invite Health vs. top competitors See 39 Invite Health Promo Codes uBiome Review Compare uBiome vs. top competitors See 2 uBiome Coupon Codes Top-ranked health & medical advice stores >>